I know, I know. The "cry-it-out" method with babies is really controversial. Since I did all my childbirth prep and gave birth at a Birth Center, I am well-versed in the pros and cons of attachment parenting and all that comes with it, and I learned that anyone who chooses attachment parenting sees the cry-it-out approach as completely cruel and traumatizing. So as a person who hasn't totally embraced attachment parenting but agrees with a lot of its techniques, I found myself in a hard place when faced with the decision with Avy: She's exhausted ... do I let her cry, or do I do everything in my power to get her to sleep myself? (And here's the real kicker...the question you can't help but ask yourself...) Which one makes me a bad mother?
It's a hard decision to make (and almost everyone I know - including my own mother - chooses not to do it), and I admit that I put it off until it first happened to me. I waited until the first time Avy collapsed into debilitating tiredness, started screaming her head off, and couldn't be consoled at all to make my decision. (You may remember me describing this situation in detail in my previous post.) But as I read my child, looked into her eyes and conjured up everything I knew in my deepest heart about her, I honestly believe that letting her cry for 5-15 minutes was the best choice for her. At first it was really hard and I questioned my decision. But then as the amount of time she cried each day decreased by 2-3 minutes, I started feeling better about it being the right way to go. And now, every time I see she's tired, I just put her down in her crib or on our bed and falls to sleep within 5 minutes without even fussing. She's amazing!
And if that weren't enough, Monday night something REALLY incredible happened: Avy slept for 9 1/2 hours straight! Hooray! At 11 weeks she slept through the night. When I woke up at 6am and couldn't remember feeding her all night, I almost went into shock. Then I checked to make sure she was still alive. She was -- and I celebrated. I always said this would be the best day of my life when it finally happened, and I have to say, I was right. I haven't slept this long since February! Just to be safe, I assumed it was a fluke and that the next night would go back to "normal" (Avy waking up every 2-5 hours to eat throughout the night, me waking up exhausted). I didn't want to get my hopes up, for my sanity's sake. But then, Tuesday night, she went down for the night at 7:30pm and didn't wake up once until 5:30am. TEN HOURS!!!! Last night the same thing happened. Life is good!
So, here's what I want to say: Cry-it-out is NOT for everyone. But I would say that if you're a confident mother who knows her child well and you really have the gut instinct that it's better for her, I commend you. I know my baby really well, and I could tell in my heart it was the best choice for her (and knew when she was crying too hard for it to benefit her -- that's key), and I am glad I made that decision.







